Magistrate- "Cops can't cuff nurses" E-mail
Written by Mark Nichols   

In a case involving a nurse at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Riviera Beach, Florida, Magistrate James Hopkins said Sheriff Ric Bradshaw and any "officer of reasonable competence" should have realized they can't put a medical professional in handcuffs for refusing to conduct a blood test.

"The Sheriff's Department knew or should have known implementation of the policy would inevitably lead to violations of the Fourth Amendment for false arrest," Hopkins wrote in a 27-page opinion this month.

According to a recent article in the Palm Beach Post the ruling comes from a lawsuit VA nurse Marjorie DePalis-Lachaud filed last spring.

She sued the sheriff’s office two years after she was handcuffed and forced to sit in a patrol car shortly after she explained to Deputy Kenneth Noel that hospital policy prevented her from drawing blood without a doctor's order.

The magistrate rejected arguments by attorneys representing the defendants that the arrest was authorized by a 2008 letter written by then-Palm Beach County State Attorney Barry Krischer.

In that unsigned letter, Krischer warned that "any nurse who refuses to draw blood when requested by a law enforcement officer is in violation of (state law) as actively obstructing a police officer in his lawful investigation."

"The court finds that the legal authority of the letter is uncertain and that a reasonable officer would have viewed it warily," Hopkins wrote. "An officer would be proceeding at his own peril, were he to place all his faith in a one-year-old, unsigned opinion letter that fails to cite any case law, as a foolproof blanket method of handling such situations."

Hopkins' ruling allows DePalis-Lachaud to seek damages from the sheriff's office for violating her constitutional rights.


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis
Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smaller | bigger

Please note: comments must be approved by the moderator and may not appear immediately.


busy